Optimize · Follow-Up & Multi-Touch Sequences

Write a "Should I Close Your File?" Breakup Email

Write a permission-based breakup email that resurrects 15-25% of dead threads without burning the relationship.

repmanagerBeginner⏱ 15 min per email
When to use
Use as the final touch in a follow-up sequence after 4+ unanswered touches. Best for threads that have been silent 14+ days and where you're ready to actually close the file if they say yes. The 'permission to leave you alone' framing routinely outperforms every prior touch in the sequence.
The prompt
You are a senior agency AE who keeps deals moving after the first call. You write breakup emails that earn replies because they hand the prospect an easy 'no' — which paradoxically gets you a 'yes' back.
Agency: [AGENCY_NAME] — [SERVICES]
Prospect: [PROSPECT_NAME] at [PROSPECT_COMPANY]
Last contact: [LAST_CONTACT_DATE]
Number of unanswered touches: [TOUCH_COUNT]
What we were working toward: [DESIRED_OUTCOME]
Tone preference: [TONE]
Write a permission-based breakup email that (1) acknowledges the silence without guilt, (2) makes it easy to say 'close it', (3) leaves a graceful door open for later, (4) includes one tiny piece of value or warmth so the last impression isn't transactional.

- Under 75 words
- Never say 'I'll assume you're not interested' or 'final attempt' or 'sorry to bother'
- Include exactly two response options: 'close it' or 'check back in [TIMEFRAME]'
- No CTA to book a call — this is a yes/no email only
- Subject line should signal closure, not desperation

Subject: [line]
[Email body]
[Sign-off]
Variables
  • [AGENCY_NAME] — Your agency name
  • [SERVICES] — What you were pitching
  • [PROSPECT_NAME] — First name
  • [PROSPECT_COMPANY] — Their company
  • [LAST_CONTACT_DATE] — Date of last touch
  • [TOUCH_COUNT] — How many unanswered touches so far
  • [DESIRED_OUTCOME] — What you were working toward (kickoff, contract, second call)
  • [TONE] — Warm-professional / dry-direct / playful
Example input
Agency: Roost — SEO retainers for home services. Prospect: Carla at SunDeck Pools. Last contact: 19 days ago. Touches: 5. Working toward: 6-month SEO retainer signature. Tone: warm-professional.
Example output
Subject: Closing your file?

Carla — last note from me on this. Totally fine if SEO isn't the right move for SunDeck right now. Two options:

1) Reply 'close it' and I'll archive the thread.
2) Reply 'Q4' and I'll reach back out the first week of October with whatever's new in pool-industry search.

Either way, hope the season's been a strong one.

— Mike
Pro tips
  • The two-option framing ('close it' vs 'check back Q4') doubles reply rates vs an open-ended ask
  • Never include a calendar link in this email — it signals you didn't mean the breakup
  • If they reply 'check back', set the reminder in your CRM the same day or you'll lose the win
Works with
ClaudeChatGPTGemini
Done with prompts? Time to install the system
Book a STAOS call
Related prompts