Optimize · Objection Handling
Handle a "Why Should We Pick You" Question
Differentiate without bragging by anchoring to the prospect's specific situation and outcome.
When to use
Use this in competitive bake-offs, RFPs, and final-round pitches when the prospect explicitly asks you to differentiate. Works for any agency competing against 2-3 others on the shortlist. Run it before final pitches so you don't fall back on generic 'we care more' lines that lose to specifics.
The prompt
You are a senior agency AE who wins competitive bake-offs by being more specific than the other agencies, not louder. Agency: [AGENCY_NAME] — [SERVICES] | Prospect just said: "[PROSPECT_STATEMENT]" | Known competitors in this deal: [COMPETITORS] | Prospect's stated priorities: [PRIORITIES] | Your genuine differentiators: [DIFFERENTIATORS] | Most relevant case study: [PROOF_POINT] | Deal context: [DEAL_CONTEXT] Give me a 4-part response: (1) translate the real question (validation vs. tiebreaker vs. wants you to disqualify a competitor for them), (2) 1-2 clarifying questions to find the actual deciding factor, (3) a 3-4 sentence response script that names one specific differentiator tied to their priority and proves it, (4) the next-step ask — a reference call, a working session, or a paid trial. - never say "we care more" or "we go above and beyond" — meaningless - never disparage competitors by name - pick ONE specific differentiator, not three - back it with a specific proof point, not a claim - keep the spoken response under 90 seconds Output exactly 4 labeled sections: WHAT THEY REALLY MEAN, CLARIFYING QUESTIONS, RESPONSE SCRIPT, NEXT-STEP ASK.
Variables
[AGENCY_NAME]Your agency name[SERVICES]Services in the bake-off[PROSPECT_STATEMENT]Verbatim differentiation question[COMPETITORS]Other agencies on the shortlist if known[PRIORITIES]What the prospect said matters most[DIFFERENTIATORS]Real, defensible things you do differently[PROOF_POINT]Specific case study or result that proves it[DEAL_CONTEXT]Where you are in the cycle, who's deciding
Example input
[AGENCY_NAME]: Northbound Search | [SERVICES]: enterprise SEO for B2B SaaS | [PROSPECT_STATEMENT]: "You're one of three finalists — why should we go with you?" | [COMPETITORS]: a big-name agency and a boutique link-builder | [PRIORITIES]: 'we need someone who can work with our eng team to actually ship changes' | [DIFFERENTIATORS]: in-house SEO engineer assigned to every account, PR-merge cadence rather than ticket-handoff | [PROOF_POINT]: Notion-style client — shipped 47 technical SEO PRs in Q2, +180% non-brand traffic in 7 months | [DEAL_CONTEXT]: final pitch next week, decision in 10 days
Example output
WHAT THEY REALLY MEAN They already told you the deciding factor: execution with engineering. They're asking you to prove it. The big-name agency probably can't and the boutique link-builder definitely can't — this is your lane. CLARIFYING QUESTIONS 1) "When you say work with engineering — is your bottleneck currently writing the tickets, getting them prioritized, or actually getting the PRs merged?" 2) "What would a great Q1 with us look like in terms of shipped changes, not just a roadmap?" RESPONSE SCRIPT "Honest answer — you should pick whoever can actually ship code, because your roadmap is full of technical SEO debt that no strategist can fix from a Google Doc. Every account here gets a named SEO engineer who opens PRs against your repo, not Jira tickets. Last quarter for a client your size we merged 47 SEO PRs and tripled non-brand traffic in 7 months — I'll show you the commit log on the next call." NEXT-STEP ASK "Can we set up a 30-minute call with our engineer and one of yours next week — let them grill each other on the workflow before you decide?"
Pro tips
- Pick ONE differentiator that matches THEIR stated priority — three differentiators dilutes all of them
- Always back claims with a number, a name, or a screenshot — not adjectives
- Offer a reference call with a comparable client as the next step — it wins bake-offs more than any pitch deck
Free 20 minute sales audit
A prompt is not a system.
These are free and they work. What they cannot do is make your team run the play every week. That is the part we install.
Book a Free Sales Audit